Concept map vs Mind map

For many people mind maps and concept maps seem to be the same thing. Thus, they are often mixed up. They resemble each other, both being used for organizing information, but they have their own distinctive functions. Let’s find out which one is better: concept map vs mind map. You will find out which one is more appropriate depending on the reason you use one of them.

Benefits

They are both graphical representations of information and many studies have shown the multiple benefits of visual learning. For instance, visual mapping improves memory and creativity, promotes better understanding, makes things easy to structure, and even improves task management.

Both are simple to use and this is one of the best leverages. Little kids, students, and adults can benefit from these tools.

These diagrams help you think outside the box. They actually imitate the way our mind thinks. They help your brain to create new connections and generate new ideas. Not to mention they are big creativity boosters.

Another great benefit is the big variety of situations when they can be used… Basically for almost anything, starting from a business plan, book summaries, to cake recipes or brainstorming sessions.

If we talk about the case of using a concept map/mind map app, you can benefit from real time collaboration. There are many software programs whose features include live collaboration. Some offer free trials or even a free version (like Mindomo) and you can test it. In other words, you can work along with other people to accomplish your goal together. “Teamwork makes the dream work”, they say.

The least, but not the last amazing thing about mind maps and concept maps is that they are attractive and engaging. It’s more pleasant and fun to create a map than to write pages of plain text, for example.

Differences: concept map vs mind map

In many personal development books, you may find mind mapping tools as recommendations.
You probably started to search more about mind mapping and you stumbled upon concept mapping.

They are often mixed up and you may be confused. Firstly, they are two different types of diagrams. Secondly, to clarify this misunderstanding let’s see which are the differences:

Concept MapMind Map
Connects multiple concepts or ideas
(a network of interconnected concepts)
Focuses on one concept
(a tree chart of organizing knowledge)
The relationships between concepts are represented by arrows with labels (they are explained). The concepts are cross linked (connected) with each other.The relationship is represented by connecting lines (they are intuitive, not directly explained)
Many-to-many relationships between conceptsSimple relationships between ideas (usually one-to-one)
More suitable for representing complex informationMore suitable for simple information, generating new ideas, note taking etc
Propositional structure (topic-label-topic usually form phrases)Non-propositional structure
Usually it is a longer process, requiring thinking in detailUsually it is a fast and spontaneous process of creation
Usually it is more objective than subjectiveUsually it is more subjective than objective
Tree structure with many branches and clustersRadial structure
Very flexible layout – free-form structureLess flexible structure compared to a concept map
concept map vs mind map - compare

Definitions: concept map vs mind map

There are many definitions to these graphic organizers, but here are the simplest and most understandable:

  • Concept map
    The concept map was developed by Dr. Joseph D. Novak from Cornell University in 1972. He defines it as a graphical representation which organizes knowledge. It includes concepts and the relationships between them indicated by linking words or linking phrases.
  • Mind map
    Tony Buzan popularized the idea of mind mapping in 1970. A mind map is defined as a diagram in which information is represented visually. Usually, it has a central idea placed in the middle and it has associated ideas arranged around it in a radial structure.

Structure and Elements

A basic mind map usually looks simpler compared to a concept map.

The concept map’s structure is characterized by 3 major features:

  • Hierarchical structure – the elements are organized starting from the most general to the most specific ones.
  • Propositional structure – thanks to the linking words (which are usually verbs), two concepts linked by a word become a statement. Basically, the whole concept map is a collection of prepositions and phrases. In other words, the concepts are cross linked.
  • Free-form structure – the layout is very flexible and it allows you to arrange the concepts however you prefer, without any limitations.

However, a mind map’s structure is:

  • Simple, usually one topic being connected with only one.
  • Radial, arranging the ideas around a central idea.

Both of them are derived by the structure of a topic map, which has 3 elements: topics, associations, and occurrences.

concept map vs mind map - Topic map

Similarly, a concept map has these elements and some specific ones:

  1. Topics  – represented by the more general concepts
  2. Subtopics  – represented by the more specific concepts
  3. Arrows – illustrate the connection between the concepts
  4. Linking words (linking phrases) – they connect the concepts and they are positioned on the arrows

On the other hand, when you create mind maps you use the following elements:

  1. Topics – illustrated by the more general ideas
  2. Subtopics  – illustrated by the more specific ideas
  3. Connecting lines – represent the relationships between ideas

Advantages and disadvantages

Concept map – Advantages Concept map – Disadvantages
More explicit than a mind map – less ambiguityTakes a longer time to be created compared to a mind map
Capable to illustrate complex informationLooks more complicated and can be less attractive
Very useful especially in educationIf it has too many topics can become hard to read
Very flexible layout
Mind map – Advantages Mind map – Disadvantages
Fast and easy to makeMay be more ambiguous
Easy to read, eye-catchingLess flexible layout
Improves creativity, great for brainstorming
Easier to collaborate with others

What and when to use: concept map vs mind map?

You can use both for organizing information. But how? Simple answer: create mind maps for simple and creative purposes and concept maps for complex matters. The best part is that you can use them in any domain: personal, work, or education.

Consequently, use a mind map app for brainstormings, book summaries, planning events or trips, organizing, to-do lists, problem-solving, note-taking, studying, etc.

However, concept maps are more suitable for studying, structuring courses, projects, business meetings, deep analysis, structuring HTML pages, vision boards, etc. In other words, use it when you need a visual structure which has complex relationships between concepts.

There is nothing nailed down, the most beautiful part of these two diagrams is that everything is flexible. When you have a great mind map but you feel like you would add some labeled relationships, you are free to do it. Make a combination and use them how it’s best for you.

When you start mapping, even if you don’t have the final visual structure in your head, just start with the central topic. Then, let the ideas flow, adding the child topics. After that, add their child topics, and so on. If you feel the need to have tacit knowledge on the map, this way it will be implied there. Don’t worry about the fact that you’ll end up having complex relationships. You will obtain a concept map and that’s perfectly fine. You can turn a mind map into a concept map anytime.

Mindomo: concept map vs mind map

Now that you’ve read all the differences between mind maps and concept maps you may be tempted to try the two. You can create both a free mind map and a free concept map using the same software: Mindomo. Why Mindomo?

Firstly, Mindomo is more than a mind map app. Compared with the other graphical tools, it’s a software that allows you to create both mind maps and concept maps. Moreover, you can also create Gantt charts and outlines. The best part is that you can turn any of these diagrams into another with only one click and you can see the difference.

Secondly, Mindomo was a web based mind mapping software, but it developed mobile apps (for Android and iOS) and a Desktop version (can be used offline). 

Moreover, it offers real time collaboration, being a great tool for businesses, teachers, and students. It is easy to use by everyone, being user-friendly. You can start your maps from scratch or use templates and personalize them how you prefer using the drag and drop functionalities and all the features available.

To be even better, you can import files from your computer, Google Drive, One Drive or Dropbox to create the best mind maps/concept maps. When you’re done you can export the mind map in many formats (Microsoft Office formats, PDF, Images, etc.)

Mindomo export


Moreover, there is a presentation mode on Mindomo which turns your mind maps and concept maps directly into a presentation without using a different tool. 

These are just some features of Mindomo, try the free version to check out all the functionalities.

If you already tried some other tools, open source software or had free trials of different mind mapping apps, leave a comment below. We’d love to hear your feedback. Let us know what other features you would like to have in Mindomo. 

Keep it smart, simple and creative!
The Mindomo Team

Write A Comment